“Puberty is a temporary mental disorder” says a character
Kirill Serebrennikov’s unnerving satirical drama The Student (2016). The film’s
protagonist Veniamin Yuzhin aka Venya (Pyotr Skvortsov) is not just going
through maddening puberty, but also caught by the allure of religious dogma. His teenage
angst mixes with fierce dedication to Christianity to stir-up collision between
two extreme schools of thought. The movie is both a reflection on the
contradictions within Russian schooling system and a universally resonant
exploration of the roots of religious zealotry (or religious totalitarianism). The
Student is based on German playwright Marius von Mayenburg’s controversial work
‘Martyr’ (The Russian title for the movie (M)uchenik plays with words as
muchenik means ‘martyr’ and uchenik means ‘student'). Director Kirill Serebrennikov (made acclaimed films like ‘Playing the Victim’, ‘Betrayal’) made
The Student through independent producers, since the Russian government would have
waved red-flag due to its political and religious themes. The movie was screened
at 2016 Cannes – in Un Certain Regard section.
The Student opens with one of many prolonged, gracefully shot argument scenes (6
minute take) between teenager Venya and his tired single mother (Yuliya Aug).
Venya has lanky, chiselled features and cloaked in total black (black t-shirt and jeans) throughout the
narrative, except for the few moments he strips his clothing. In the heightened
conversation, Venya and his mother move through the closed quarters of
apartment, bickering over swimming classes, school life, and his newly found
vigorous love for God. Venya often launches into religious tirade, integrating
texts from Bible to support his argument. We wonder whether the teenager is
just using Bible verses as a means to get to his mother or maybe overturn the whole
apparatus of authority. The reason behind Venya’s rejection of swimming classes
has spiritual perspective: as per the law recited by God, he is protesting
against the bikini-wears of the female classmates. He even jumps into the pool,
fully-clothed.
The silly antics of Venya make his mother to seek help from
school administration. Headmistress (Svetlana Bragarnik) and most of her
faculty finds the boy’s reasoning to be valid and imposes the rule of swim-suits.
The open-minded biology teacher Elena (Victoria Isakova) disapproves the
decision. In fact, she becomes Venya’s only rival. He launches into violent
denunciations right in the middle of her class. It starts with ‘sex-education’
class, and to Elena’s dismay continues in the ‘evolution’ class. Instead of
controlling Venya’s outburst and condemning his archaic, fundamentalist views, the
headmistress turns a blind-eye, finding Elena’s teachings to be too progressive
for the students. “The Church needs more people like you” says the school
priest. Venya also attracts adoration from couple of classmates – the class
heartthrob Lidia (Aleksandra Revenko) and the bullied Grigoriy (Aleksandr
Gorchilin). However, both the classmates’ interests are interested in physical
closeness than the spiritual. Moreover, Venya finds it very hard to shake off
Grigoriy’s affections for him. Venya also decides to do the ‘necessary’ in
order to spread his dominant religious doctrine.
The film reaches fascinating heights when it pits the two
ideologically different personalities (Venya and Elena) for the verbal clashes.
The teenager’s literal interpretation of the ambiguous scriptures and his rigid
recitation of Bible passages disorientate Elena, who is looking to find foothold
through scientific reasoning. Nevertheless, the old peoples in authority find
it easy to kow-tow to conservatism than progressive ideals. It’s an indictment
of the unprecedented rise of orthodoxy in Russia. Furthermore, in a broader sense it explores
the little steps that put our societies in the paths of totalitarianism. Director
Serebrennikov and DP Vladislav Opelyants (worked in the films of renowned
Russian film-maker Nikita Mikhalkov) have done an excellent job in creating
this kinetic film-form. Many of the sequences are shot in long takes (after
repeated rehearsals). The presence of Venya, dressed in black and speaking with
booming voice, starkly reflects the catastrophe he is waiting to unleash.
Except for Elena and Venya, Serebrennikov frames other supporting characters as
beings solely anchored in bodily existence (by bowing to fundamentalism and
clinging to physical desires).
Yet, for all its riveting
staging and relevant social commentary, The Student never turns into a profound
piece. Part of the reason lies in the characterization, which doesn’t have much
depth and even at times threatens to turn into caricatures. Venya’s sermons do
tend to cause fatigue in the latter parts, largely because the character
remains the same; he doesn’t go through an arc. It is understandable that the
pains of adulthood has set him to embrace God (in a fierce manner), but we
definitely can’t empathize with him. The same goes for Elena, whose ideals
makes us side with her, but we aren’t fully devastated by her emotional
conflicts. The glimpse of empathy is seen within Grigoriy, although his
character arc offers nothing new (or of importance). Thankfully, the haunting
ending and the terrific central performances – from Skvortsov and Isakova – doesn’t
completely lessen the impact of the subject matter.
Trailer
The Student (114 minutes) is an intriguing parable on
religious fundamentalism which often serves as point of aggression and terrorism
between two individuals or even nations. Despite its on-the-nose symbolism and
near-exhausting sermons, its rounds of moral wrestling leave us with lot to
contemplate.
★★★½
1 comment:
This one too looks great.
Post a Comment